I don’t think it will. I think he’s too versatile to pass on over any perceived shoulder issue he may or may not have.
It’s similar to Randy Moss. He haunted the teams that passed on him. The Randy Moss Factor lives.
Moderators: rtb, kmax, SonomaCat
I don’t think it will. I think he’s too versatile to pass on over any perceived shoulder issue he may or may not have.
Randy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
Sorry papa but TA wasn't just great because he played at the FCS level. And I know that's not exactly what you are saying, but it comes off that way. Had he played at the FBS level for 4-5 years at 1 position he would be a round 1 pick. He might even be a round 1 pick had he played LB for 4 years at MSU.PapaG wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 9:32 pmRandy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
There were zero concerns about him as a WR and zero concerns about him coming off injuries. Lou Holtz called him the greatest HS player he’d ever seen. Bobby Bowden compared him to Deion Sanders as greatest player to step foot in that program. Troy Andersen is a very good football player who has minimal experience at his position and made up for it with elite athleticism which made him a great player at the FCS level. We all hope Troy becomes one of the best ever to play his position, but Randy Moss was viewed as a potential All-Pro NFL player is ever get his head on straight going back to his HS recruiting.
This is the type of hyperbolic nonsense that puts way too high of expectations on 15 by even bringing up Moss and makes this board look as delusional as egris. It doesn’t matter which round Troy gets drafted in, it matters what he does on the field.
Tell me you were passed out drunk for every one of MSU’s football games without telling me you were passed drunk for every one of MSU’s football games.PapaG wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 9:32 pmRandy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
There were zero concerns about him as a WR and zero concerns about him coming off injuries. Lou Holtz called him the greatest HS player he’d ever seen. Bobby Bowden compared him to Deion Sanders as greatest player to step foot in that program. Troy Andersen is a very good football player who has minimal experience at his position and made up for it with elite athleticism which made him a great player at the FCS level. We all hope Troy becomes one of the best ever to play his position, but Randy Moss was viewed as a potential All-Pro NFL player is ever get his head on straight going back to his HS recruiting.
This is the type of hyperbolic nonsense that puts way too high of expectations on 15 by even bringing up Moss and makes this board look as delusional as egris. It doesn’t matter which round Troy gets drafted in, it matters what he does on the field.
If Troy was viewed today as the next Brian Uhrlacher at MLB by the NFL, he’d be in the discussion as the #1 overall pick because there are no off-the-field concerns about him at all. He’s not viewed as Uhrlacher, or the LB version of Moss, which is why he’s a Day 2 pick. It’s not demeaning to Troy to state the obvious. Troy was an all-time great FCS player. I can’t extrapolate that elite success to an elite FBS program because that wasn’t how his college career unfolded.BleedingBLue wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 10:03 pmSorry papa but TA wasn't just great because he played at the FCS level. And I know that's not exactly what you are saying, but it comes off that way. Had he played at the FBS level for 4-5 years at 1 position he would be a round 1 pick. He might even be a round 1 pick had he played LB for 4 years at MSU.PapaG wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 9:32 pmRandy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
There were zero concerns about him as a WR and zero concerns about him coming off injuries. Lou Holtz called him the greatest HS player he’d ever seen. Bobby Bowden compared him to Deion Sanders as greatest player to step foot in that program. Troy Andersen is a very good football player who has minimal experience at his position and made up for it with elite athleticism which made him a great player at the FCS level. We all hope Troy becomes one of the best ever to play his position, but Randy Moss was viewed as a potential All-Pro NFL player is ever get his head on straight going back to his HS recruiting.
This is the type of hyperbolic nonsense that puts way too high of expectations on 15 by even bringing up Moss and makes this board look as delusional as egris. It doesn’t matter which round Troy gets drafted in, it matters what he does on the field.
I don’t understand why me not immediately comparing him to NFL Hall of Famers is worthy of this response. Why will you be laughing at me for not expecting him to be one of the greatest NFL players in history before he’s even on a team?TomCat88 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 1:55 amTell me you were passed out drunk for every one of MSU’s football games without telling me you were passed drunk for every one of MSU’s football games.PapaG wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 9:32 pmRandy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
There were zero concerns about him as a WR and zero concerns about him coming off injuries. Lou Holtz called him the greatest HS player he’d ever seen. Bobby Bowden compared him to Deion Sanders as greatest player to step foot in that program. Troy Andersen is a very good football player who has minimal experience at his position and made up for it with elite athleticism which made him a great player at the FCS level. We all hope Troy becomes one of the best ever to play his position, but Randy Moss was viewed as a potential All-Pro NFL player is ever get his head on straight going back to his HS recruiting.
This is the type of hyperbolic nonsense that puts way too high of expectations on 15 by even bringing up Moss and makes this board look as delusional as egris. It doesn’t matter which round Troy gets drafted in, it matters what he does on the field.![]()
Troy Andersen IS a generational player. Just because he’s at Montana State and no “big time” teams like Oregonwere forward thinking enough to have someone come out and give him a look doesn’t mean he isn’t. The dude has literally blown all the other linebackers away on average in the combine and his pro day. The all time combine record in the 40 is 4.38 and that dude isn’t half the size or skill of Andersen.
Just like Moss compared to receivers that have slightly better 40 times. Moss was drafted 21st. Should’ve been much earlier, like at least second. Andersen will most likely be taken too late and teams will be kicking themselves when he’s a game one starter and starting in the Pro Bowl.
People keep doubting him. I remember comparing him to OJ Simpson before his freshman year and people laughed. A year after getting frosh of the year he’s setting the BSC quarterback rushing record.
Teams know Andersen is a stud. Some will gamble in hopes of getting him in a later round. When he’s selected to start in the Pro Bowl, they’ll be crying in their beer. Just like the Cowboys and Bears.
After the draft it’ll be interesting to find out which teams told Troy they were going to take him but didn’t.He’ll be laughing at them and I’ll be laughing at you and all his other low FCS self esteem others.
![]()
![]()
Yeah, the simple fact that he's being talked about as a 2nd round pick at LB despite playing two of his four years of college on offense is pretty damn incredible on its own. I think all of us agree that Troy is going to be a very good NFL player and has the potential to develop into an elite one - just cross your fingers that your favorite team drafts him (or at least that your team's hated rival doesn't), and enjoy the ride!BelligerentBobcat wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 8:34 amRandy Moss has a legitimate case as the most talented WR in NFL history, and one could argue the best WR period. He “forced” a team to spend 3 high draft picks on CB’s just to help cover him (one of them was Joey Thomas). I love Troy as a player, he’s fantastic, I think he’ll have a good NFL career…but they aren’t remotely close to the same tier, level, impact, whatever you want to call it. Let’s just enjoy Troy for what he is.
I think he'd definitely be a late round 1 or early round 2 pick out of MSU if he had played LB, and only LB, and only one LB position, for even just the last two years. He wouldn't have split his focus across positions / sides of the ball, he'd probably be less likely to be injured, and thus have fewer medical flags pre-draft. Hell, he's currently a likely round 2 pick based mostly on athleticism and potential. Imagine if he had that, plus positional experience and a clean bill of health. Any more than 2 years at one position and he'd be a lock for the first round.BleedingBLue wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 10:03 pmSorry papa but TA wasn't just great because he played at the FCS level. And I know that's not exactly what you are saying, but it comes off that way. Had he played at the FBS level for 4-5 years at 1 position he would be a round 1 pick. He might even be a round 1 pick had he played LB for 4 years at MSU.PapaG wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 9:32 pmRandy Moss was a generational player in high school that ended up at Marshall because he didn’t qualify academically at Notre Dame after serving time in jail in West Virginia, and then character problems at Florida State for smoking weed.
There were zero concerns about him as a WR and zero concerns about him coming off injuries. Lou Holtz called him the greatest HS player he’d ever seen. Bobby Bowden compared him to Deion Sanders as greatest player to step foot in that program. Troy Andersen is a very good football player who has minimal experience at his position and made up for it with elite athleticism which made him a great player at the FCS level. We all hope Troy becomes one of the best ever to play his position, but Randy Moss was viewed as a potential All-Pro NFL player is ever get his head on straight going back to his HS recruiting.
This is the type of hyperbolic nonsense that puts way too high of expectations on 15 by even bringing up Moss and makes this board look as delusional as egris. It doesn’t matter which round Troy gets drafted in, it matters what he does on the field.
I said all that about Moss BEFORE he was drafted, too. Obvious talent and skills. Just like Andersen. But also both possess that special something…vision, intuition…BelligerentBobcat wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 8:34 amRandy Moss has a legitimate case as the most talented WR in NFL history, and one could argue the best WR period. He “forced” a team to spend 3 high draft picks on CB’s just to help cover him (one of them was Joey Thomas). I love Troy as a player, he’s fantastic, I think he’ll have a good NFL career…but they aren’t remotely close to the same tier, level, impact, whatever you want to call it. Let’s just enjoy Troy for what he is.
Not only that, but the URL link article spelled his name incorrectly.
My hunch is that he goes in the late 2nd round to a team that either has a ton of picks, or already has a solid defense and can give Troy another year or two to learn the intricacies of the LB position before throwing him in there as a starter right away. Troy should be a special teams standout from Day 1 though if his team chooses to use him there.
Vikings are taking him in the second round if he’s still available. The highest I’ve heard him going so far is first round to New England, but that depends on if one other player hasn’t been taken.MSU01 wrote: ↑Mon Apr 11, 2022 6:56 amMy hunch is that he goes in the late 2nd round to a team that either has a ton of picks, or already has a solid defense and can give Troy another year or two to learn the intricacies of the LB position before throwing him in there as a starter right away. Troy should be a special teams standout from Day 1 though if his team chooses to use him there.