2 weeks

[GoCats18]

2 weeks later and the griz are still talking about the instant replay call. At least now big brothers dad has spoken up. Way to go Fullerton, once again you have shown that all you care about is the griz. The Big Sky would be a way better conference without Fullerton, time to clean house BSC........

http://missoulian.com/college/griz/spel ... 963f4.html

[LongTimeCatFan]

I read that completely different. Fullerton is using that play to justify the need for replay during the regular season since officials don't really know how to use it in the post season.

Any of us that have complained about the refs would think this to be a positive step forward. Also, all of the coaches want it, so I hope it happens.

[77matcat]

Not a Fullerton fan, but think he is positioning for an instant replay push. With BSC refers makes makes good sense to me.

Not sure how many additional cameras are needed. Anyone have an idea re logistics????

[GoCats18]

I agree that Fullerton is asking for better replay, I just know he wouldn't have spoken up like he did had MSU had this same thing happen in a playoff game. You have officials working with something they only use once or twice a year, you know something is going to happen. That play had very little to do with the outcome of the game. Yes you had a play taken back, but you had 4 more chances to get a first down. Isn't that how the game is played, 4 downs to get a first?

[Jobu]

This is an odd thread. When did Fullerton become a Griz? And while I agree it's time for him to move on, I actually agree with him here.

And yes, that play -- at least potentially -- had a huge impact on that game. If something like that had happened to the Cats, we'd be outraged, and rightfully so. Mind you, this wasn't an error on a judgment call. This was a complete misapplication of rules that my 2nd grade nephew understands. Once a play is run there cannot be replay. And then to refuse to put the nearly minute of game time lost to the "play that never happened"? Remarkably horrible officiating, and Fullerton was right to point that out and ask for changes.

[Grizlaw]

That play had very little to do with the outcome of the game. Yes you had a play taken back, but you had 4 more chances to get a first down. Isn't that how the game is played, 4 downs to get a first?

Sorry to be a little late to this thread - I wasn't online much over the holidays, and I'm still getting caught up.

By your logic, no blown call can ever affect the outcome of a game, because no matter how badly a ref f*cks up, the other team always has (or has had) other plays in which they could've gotten the first down (or gotten the stop, if the bad call is against the defense). So what does that mean? No matter how badly the refs screw up, nobody should ever complain?

I agree that this play probably didn't change the outcome, but that doesn't mean Fullerton (or Griz fans) are wrong to complain about it. It truly was one of the worst officiating blunders I have ever seen in any sport. It's hard for me to envision a scenario more worthy of ref-bashing than this one.

[CARDIAC_CATS]

That play had very little to do with the outcome of the game. Yes you had a play taken back, but you had 4 more chances to get a first down. Isn't that how the game is played, 4 downs to get a first?

Sorry to be a little late to this thread - I wasn't online much over the holidays, and I'm still getting caught up.

By your logic, no blown call can ever affect the outcome of a game, because no matter how badly a ref f*cks up, the other team always has (or has had) other plays in which they could've gotten the first down (or gotten the stop, if the bad call is against the defense). So what does that mean? No matter how badly the refs screw up, nobody should ever complain?

I agree that this play probably didn't change the outcome, but that doesn't mean Fullerton (or Griz fans) are wrong to complain about it. It truly was one of the worst officiating blunders I have ever seen in any sport. It's hard for me to envision a scenario more worthy of ref-bashing than this one.

As my high school coach once said. If you keep the game close enough that a Referee error can affect the game, then you didn't do enough to win the game outright by yourselves anyway (i.e. no excuses or crying). Bad bounces, freak plays, referee blunders are going to happen every week. Good teams overcome them.

[Jobu]

That play had very little to do with the outcome of the game. Yes you had a play taken back, but you had 4 more chances to get a first down. Isn't that how the game is played, 4 downs to get a first?

Sorry to be a little late to this thread - I wasn't online much over the holidays, and I'm still getting caught up.

By your logic, no blown call can ever affect the outcome of a game, because no matter how badly a ref f*cks up, the other team always has (or has had) other plays in which they could've gotten the first down (or gotten the stop, if the bad call is against the defense). So what does that mean? No matter how badly the refs screw up, nobody should ever complain?

I agree that this play probably didn't change the outcome, but that doesn't mean Fullerton (or Griz fans) are wrong to complain about it. It truly was one of the worst officiating blunders I have ever seen in any sport. It's hard for me to envision a scenario more worthy of ref-bashing than this one.

As my high school coach once said. If you keep the game close enough that a Referee error can affect the game, then you didn't do enough to win the game outright by yourselves anyway (i.e. no excuses or crying). Bad bounces, freak plays, referee blunders are going to happen every week. Good teams overcome them.

Oh I don't think anyone disagrees with that point at all.

But does that mean that Fullerton shouldn't point out what was a RIDICULOUS and egregious error in officiating which potentially harmed one of his conference's teams? Again, this wasn't a judgement call. This was a rule that 99.999999997% of anyone who has watched a football game understands. And the DI officials getting paid to officiate a playoff game somehow found a way to f*ck up that rule.

That deserves to be called out. And I'm glad Fullerton had the balls to do so.